National Academies Hosts 2026 Mark Kleiman Innovation for Public Policy Memorial Lecture
The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) hosted its 2026 Mark Kleiman Innovation for Public Policy Memorial Lecture, featuring Dr. Maria Cuellar, associate professor of criminology, statistics, and data science at the University of Pennsylvania. The annual lecture recognizes an early-career investigator whose research informs criminal justice decision-making and public policy. Cuellar, whose work examines the intersection of statistics and law, delivered a lecture titled, “Can We Trust the Science?” examining the reliability and validity of forensic evidence used in criminal proceedings.
Cuellar discussed the limitations of existing forensic methods, focusing on firearm and tool mark comparisons and the lack of rigorous research establishing their accuracy. She highlighted significant methodological flaws that prevent reliable conclusions about examiner error rates by drawing on research reviewing 28 studies of firearm comparisons. She also explored the potential for statistical algorithms and machine learning to improve forensic comparisons, emphasizing the importance of validating both the technology and the human-machine processes involved. Addressing the growing use of generative artificial intelligence in the criminal justice system, Cuellar argued that new technologies must be rigorously tested before they are adopted in legal proceedings. She concluded that scientific validation is essential to preventing wrongful convictions, reducing miscarriages of justice, and maintaining public trust in the criminal justice system.
This article was contributed by COSSA Intern Ananya Bamidipati.